TL;DR
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after Tuesday’s Super Bowl-themed episode. Jimmy Kimmel criticized the result on Jimmy Kimmel Live, pointing to the pair’s online support and their highest judges’ score of the season, 22 out of 40.
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after Tuesday’s Super Bowl-themed episode, prompting Jimmy Kimmel to criticize the viewer vote on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Kimmel said the pair had drawn strong online attention and noted that their judges’ score of 22 out of 40 was Guillermo’s highest of the season, but they were again in the bottom two and did not receive enough viewer support to stay.
Get movie nights delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The episode featured Guillermo and Carson performing a Salsa to Bad Bunny. The judges awarded them 22 points out of 40: Carrie Ann Inaba gave them a 6, Derek Hough a 5, Joe Buck a 6 and Bruno Tonioli a 5. Kimmel described the performance as an 11 out of 10 in his view, while making clear that the official panel’s scores were lower.
On his show, Kimmel also presented a comparison of the pair’s YouTube views from the previous week. The chart showed 719,000 views for Guillermo and Carson and 231,000 for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, who were listed second. Kimmel also played clips of news programs in the United States and Canada expressing support for Guillermo. Those examples and view counts indicate visible attention, but they do not establish how viewers voted or explain the elimination.
After the results, Kimmel spoke live with Guillermo and Carson backstage at the ballroom. When Kimmel jokingly asked whether they would accept the outcome or take legal action, Guillermo said they should take legal action, and Carson agreed. The exchange was presented as humor, not an announcement of an actual legal challenge. Kimmel praised Carson’s choreography and asked Guillermo what he had achieved during the competition. Guillermo said he had set out to lose weight and had done so.
DWTS · Week 5 · The Results
The Elimination That Prompted Jimmy Kimmel to Slam Voters
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson’s run ended after a Super Bowl-themed Salsa, despite a season-high judges’ score and visible online support. Kimmel questioned the result; the show’s vote totals remain undisclosed.
“An 11 out of 10.”
His personal rating of the Salsa · Official score: 22/40Season high for Guillermo
Guillermo & Witney, previous week
Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson
Scheduled theme: Dedication Night
A season best, but not enough to stay
Guillermo and Carson performed a Salsa to Bad Bunny during Tuesday’s Super Bowl-themed episode. Four judges scored the dance.
How the 22 points broke down
Eliminated in Week 5
The pair were again in the bottom two, according to Kimmel’s account. Their run ended after the episode’s viewer vote.
Support was visible
Kimmel cited online attention and supportive media clips. Those examples show interest, but they do not reveal how viewers voted.
A view count is not a vote count
Kimmel’s chart compared YouTube views from the previous week. It measured views, not votes cast in the competition.
A reported gap in views
Guillermo and Carson’s video had more than triple the views of the next team listed in Kimmel’s comparison.
Views do not establish voting behavior or explain the elimination.
Two inputs shape who advances
The episode put the gap between a strong performance score and the final result in focus. Full voting figures were not reported.
Perform
The pair danced a Salsa to Bad Bunny on Super Bowl theme night.
Judges score
The panel awarded 22 out of 40, Guillermo’s season high.
Viewers vote
Viewer votes help determine which contestants remain; totals were not disclosed here.
Elimination
Guillermo and Carson were sent home after landing in the bottom two again.
Backstage banter, not a legal announcement
Kimmel spoke with the pair live backstage. Their exchange about taking legal action was presented as a joke.
“Jimmy, I said I was going to lose weight and I did lose weight.”
Guillermo Rodriguez · Backstage with Jimmy Kimmel“You can have him now.”
Witney Carson · A joking “custody battle” remarkDedication Night is scheduled next
Guillermo and Carson’s competition run is over. The available details do not include a show statement explaining the vote outcome.
Scheduled for the next episode.
ABC and Disney+ · Eastern and Pacific time
Episodes available the following day, according to the published schedule.
Online Attention Did Not Secure Votes
The elimination highlights the difference between visible enthusiasm for a contestant and the voting that determines who remains on the show. Kimmel’s chart pointed to a large gap in YouTube views, while his clips showed media figures rooting for Guillermo. Neither measure reveals the total number of votes cast, how votes were distributed among contestants, or whether online viewers also voted.
The result also puts the show’s two-part scoring process in view: judges assign performance scores, while viewer votes help determine who advances. Guillermo’s season-high score of 22 did not keep him in the competition. Kimmel’s reaction gave the result attention beyond the ballroom, but his criticism was a personal response as a supporter of Guillermo and Carson, not evidence that the vote was mishandled.
Popular right now
KitchenAid 5.5-Quart Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer, Porcelain White
Philips Baristina Espresso Machine with Milk Frother (BAR308/60)
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds (2nd Gen), Wireless Noise-Cancelling Earbuds with Immersive Audio and Wireless Charging Case, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Guillermo’s Week Five Run
Guillermo, known as a longtime presence on Jimmy Kimmel’s program, competed with professional dancer Witney Carson during the season. Kimmel had publicly supported the pair throughout their run. By Week 5, the team had become a subject of online discussion, and Kimmel said they had been prominent with viewers and media outlets.
Before the elimination, Guillermo had already been in the bottom two in an earlier results show, according to Kimmel’s account. He said Guillermo had relied on viewers to get through that result. Tuesday’s outcome ended their run despite the higher score for their latest dance. The show’s next episode is scheduled to have a “Dedication Night” theme.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel, on Jimmy Kimmel Live
Voting Figures Remain Unreported
The available account does not give official vote totals, the voting margin between contestants, or the full results that placed Guillermo and Carson in the bottom two. YouTube views and supportive clips are not a substitute for those figures, so they cannot show whether online attention translated into votes or why the pair were eliminated.
There is also no indication that Guillermo or Carson intend to pursue legal action; the exchange with Kimmel was framed as a joke. The published details do not include a statement from the show explaining the vote outcome or further breakdowns of the judges’ and viewers’ contributions.
Dedication Night Follows Week Five
Dancing with the Stars is scheduled to continue next Tuesday with “Dedication Night.” The program airs on ABC and Disney+ at 8 p.m. Eastern and Pacific time, with episodes streaming on Hulu the following day, according to the published schedule.
Guillermo and Carson’s competition run is over. Any fuller account of how the vote was decided would depend on additional information from the show; none is included in the details of Kimmel’s reaction. Until then, his response remains a public critique of the result, while the underlying viewer vote totals remain undisclosed.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Key Questions
Who was eliminated from Dancing with the Stars?
Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson were eliminated after the Week 5 Super Bowl-themed episode.
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize the result?
Kimmel objected to the elimination, pointing to the pair’s reported YouTube views, public support and Guillermo’s highest judges’ score of the season. His comments were his reaction to the result, not an explanation of the official vote.
What score did Guillermo and Witney receive?
The judges gave their Salsa performance 22 out of 40: Inaba and Buck each awarded 6, while Hough and Tonioli each awarded 5.
Did Guillermo and Witney announce plans to sue?
No legal action was announced. Guillermo and Carson agreed jokingly when Kimmel asked whether they would take legal action over the elimination.
What is the next Dancing with the Stars theme?
The next episode is scheduled as “Dedication Night.” The show airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. Eastern and Pacific on ABC and Disney+, with episodes available on Hulu the following day.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
