Among celebrity makeup palettes, these three licensed collaborations take different routes: ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon offers the widest mix of wearable and smoky shades, r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest brings greens and playful color into a more flexible 12-pan layout, and ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse leans into silver, taupe, and blood red. I rank New Moon first for its range of finishes and broader use across neutral and dramatic looks. Ozian Forest is my pick for shoppers who want a green-centered palette with everyday options, while Eclipse makes more sense for a deliberate vampy aesthetic. The tradeoff is straightforward: more color variety can mean a less focused palette, while a distinct theme may limit how often you reach for it.
Get movie-night favorites delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- New Moon ranks first for shoppers who want 15 shades spanning warm neutrals, berry, and black, with matte, shimmer, glitter, and metallic finishes.
- Ozian Forest is the most distinctive choice for forest greens and a green duochrome, balanced by earthy neutrals and jewel tones.
- Eclipse is the most focused palette: silver, taupe, and blood red suit cool-toned and vampy looks better than an everyday-neutral brief.
- All three are eyeshadow palettes rather than full-face celebrity makeup kits; none is described as including application tools.
- The ColourPop Twilight palettes are both limited-edition collections, while the available details for Ozian Forest do not establish its release status or wear performance.
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon Eyeshadow Palette, 15-Pan, 0.6 oz |  | Best Overall — broadest mix of wearable and smoky looks | Brand: ColourPop | Collection: The Twilight Saga: New Moon | Product type: Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest Eyeshadow Palette, 12 Shades |  | Best for Color Lovers — green-led with room for softer looks | Brand: r.e.m. beauty | Collection: Wicked: For Good | Product type: Eyeshadow palette | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse Eyeshadow Palette, 15 Shades |  | Best for Vampy Looks — focused silver, taupe, and blood-red shades | Brand: ColourPop | Collection: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse | Product type: Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| celebrity makeup palette | Brand | Collection | Product type | Shade count |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: | ColourPop | The Twilight Saga: New Moon | Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | 15 |
| r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Go | r.e.m. beauty | Wicked: For Good | Eyeshadow palette | 12 |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | ColourPop | The Twilight Saga: Eclipse | Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | 15 |
More Details on Our Top Picks
ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon Eyeshadow Palette, 15-Pan, 0.6 oz
New Moon earns my overall pick because its 15 shades cross several lanes without committing the entire palette to a single dramatic color story. Warm neutrals can anchor simpler looks, while berry and black shades give buyers a route to more defined or smoky makeup. That range is more flexible on paper than Eclipse, whose silver, taupe, and blood-red selection has a stronger, narrower mood. The combination is particularly useful for someone drawn to the Twilight collaboration but hoping to wear more than a themed evening look.
The finish mix also supports that versatility: the palette includes matte, shimmer, pearlescent glitter, and metallic options. Different textures can add contrast without requiring a second palette, though 15 shades and several statement finishes may feel like more choice than a minimalist buyer wants. Its buildable, blendable formula is described as designed for smooth application with reduced fallout. Those are helpful formulation aims, but the supplied details do not establish how the shades wear on different skin types or how much fallout occurs in practice.
Compared with Ozian Forest, New Moon favors warm neutrals, berry, and black rather than making forest green its defining feature. That gives it a more conventional route from low-key to smoky, while Ozian Forest will appeal more to anyone specifically seeking green and duochrome. New Moon is also described as vegan and cruelty-free; Eclipse is identified as cruelty-free, but not as vegan in the supplied specifications. Its chief limitation is availability: the collection is described as limited edition, and application tools are not specified as included. I would skip it if the buyer wants mostly greens, dislikes glitter, or needs a confirmed long-wear claim.
Pros:- 15 shades span warm neutrals, berry, and black.
- Matte, shimmer, pearlescent glitter, and metallic finishes support varied looks.
- Formula is described as buildable, blendable, and designed to help reduce fallout.
- Listed as vegan and cruelty-free.
Cons:- Limited-edition status may make it harder to find consistently.
- Application tools are not specified as included.
- The glitter and multiple finish types may be unnecessary for buyers who prefer a simple matte palette.
Best for: Buyers who want a Twilight-themed palette that can support warm neutral, berry, and smoky looks without relying on one signature color.
Not ideal for: Minimalists seeking only everyday matte neutrals, shoppers who want a green-led story, or anyone who needs brushes confirmed in the package.
- Brand:ColourPop
- Collection:The Twilight Saga: New Moon
- Product type:Pressed powder eyeshadow palette
- Shade count:15
- Color range:Warm neutrals, berry, and black
- Finishes:Matte, shimmer, pearlescent glitter, and metallic
- Weight:0.6 oz
- Formula notes:Buildable, blendable; designed to help reduce fallout
- Animal testing and formula status:Vegan and cruelty-free
Our verdict“I recommend New Moon as the most flexible pick here for buyers who want a wide Twilight-inspired color story rather than a narrowly themed edit.”
r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest Eyeshadow Palette, 12 Shades
Ozian Forest is my choice for buyers who want a celebrity collaboration that feels visibly different from a standard neutral palette. Its forest greens, jewel tones, and green duochrome give the collection a clear identity, while earthy neutrals offer a softer counterpoint. That split matters: compared with Eclipse’s silver, taupe, and blood-red focus, Ozian Forest builds its drama around green and adds more earthy shades to temper it. It is the most direct fit for a shopper who wants color without buying a palette made exclusively of bright statement tones.
The 12-shade layout is smaller than the two 15-pan ColourPop options. A more compact shade count can make the color story easier to understand, though the provided information does not identify the exact shades or their placement. Its velvety mattes, shimmers, metallics, and duochrome create several texture options, and the formula is described as blendable. That suggests the palette is intended to move between everyday and dramatic looks, but the available details do not verify wear time, fallout, or performance across skin tones. I would not treat those unknowns as proof of a problem; they are simply unanswered questions for a buyer comparing formulas.
Compared with New Moon, Ozian Forest trades some breadth in shade count and the stated vegan-and-cruelty-free detail for a more unusual green-centered theme. Compared with Eclipse, it offers earthy neutrals and a broader mix of color families rather than a predominantly vampy direction. That makes it the better choice for someone who enjoys color experimentation, but less convincing for a buyer who rarely wears green or wants a highly predictable neutral set. The supplied product details also give no customer review content to help clarify wear or performance, so I place it behind New Moon for all-purpose versatility rather than claiming it performs worse.
Pros:- Green-led color story stands apart from both Twilight palettes.
- Earthy neutrals and jewel tones allow more than one intensity of look.
- Matte, shimmer, metallic, and duochrome finishes add texture variety.
- Blendable formula is described as suited to everyday or dramatic makeup.
Cons:- The supplied details do not establish wear time or real-world performance.
- At 12 shades, it has fewer pans than either ColourPop palette.
- Its forest-green focus may be limiting for buyers who mostly wear neutral or warm shades.
Best for: Makeup buyers who want a Wicked collaboration with forest greens, a duochrome accent, and neutrals that can soften a colorful look.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who avoid green, need confirmed wear or fallout information before choosing, or prefer a larger set of classic neutral shades.
- Brand:r.e.m. beauty
- Collection:Wicked: For Good
- Product type:Eyeshadow palette
- Shade count:12
- Color range:Forest greens, earthy neutrals, jewel tones, and pops of color
- Finishes:Matte, shimmer, metallic, and duochrome
- Formula description:Blendable; described as velvety in matte finishes
- Intended looks:Everyday or dramatic
Our verdict“I would choose Ozian Forest over the Twilight palettes when green color and a distinctive duochrome matter more than a broadly neutral shade mix.”
ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse Eyeshadow Palette, 15 Shades
Eclipse is the most tightly themed option in this lineup. Its silver, taupe, and blood-red shades point toward cool-toned, smoky, and vampy makeup rather than a broad set of everyday color options. That focus is a strength for fans who want the Eclipse story reflected in the palette; they are not being asked to translate a generic neutral selection into the theme. But the same focus makes it less adaptable than New Moon, whose warm neutrals, berry, and black provide more obvious routes into both softer and deeper looks.
The 15-shade pressed powder palette includes matte, metallic, and glitter finishes. Its formula is described as pigmented, blendable, and designed for long wear, which makes layering and building a look part of the intended use. Those stated attributes are appealing for shoppers who want richer color or a more dramatic eye, though they are not a promise of identical results for everyone. The supplied specifications do not include a detailed shade-by-shade breakdown, tools, or testing information, so buyers should not assume every pan is equally wearable or that application requires no extras.
Against Ozian Forest, Eclipse swaps green and earthy neutrals for a colder, more theatrical palette. If green is the priority, r.e.m. beauty is the clearer match; if the aim is blood red with silver and taupe, Eclipse has the more precise color story. It is also listed as cruelty-free, while New Moon is the one explicitly identified as both vegan and cruelty-free in the supplied information. Limited-edition status is another practical drawback, and the vampy range will not suit every preference. I place Eclipse third overall because it serves a narrower brief, not because its focused identity lacks appeal.
Pros:- 15 shades offer a defined silver, taupe, and blood-red color story.
- Matte, metallic, and glitter finishes suit layered, dramatic looks.
- Formula is described as pigmented, blendable, and designed for long wear.
- Listed as cruelty-free.
Cons:- Limited-edition collection may not remain readily available.
- Vampy colors may see less use for buyers who prefer subtle everyday makeup.
- Vegan status and included application tools are not specified in the provided details.
Best for: Twilight fans and makeup wearers who specifically want silver, taupe, and blood-red shades for cool, smoky, or vampy looks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a flexible everyday palette, prefer warm neutrals or greens, or want vegan status confirmed in the listed specifications.
- Brand:ColourPop
- Collection:The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
- Product type:Pressed powder eyeshadow palette
- Shade count:15
- Color range:Silver, taupe, and blood red
- Finishes:Matte, metallic, and glitter
- Weight:0.63 oz
- Formula description:Pigmented and blendable; designed for long wear
- Animal testing status:Cruelty-free
Our verdict“Eclipse is my pick for a deliberately cool, vampy Twilight look, but New Moon is the safer choice if you need a wider everyday-to-dramatic range.”
How We Picked
I ranked these options as celebrity collaboration eyeshadow palettes, not as general makeup kits. The collection theme matters, but a name or tie-in alone does not make a palette useful; I also weighed the shade range, finish mix, stated formula attributes, and how readily the colors could serve more than one kind of look. That is why New Moon takes the top spot: its warm neutrals, berry tones, and black give it a wider stated range of possible uses than Eclipse’s more focused silver, taupe, and blood-red edit.
I gave Ozian Forest a separate role rather than treating its green focus as a weakness. Its forest shades and duochrome are the clearest match for buyers seeking color, while earthy neutrals provide a way to keep the palette from being all statement shades. Eclipse places third not because a focused palette is inherently worse, but because the supplied color story has a narrower everyday fit. It may be the strongest match for someone specifically seeking vampy shades, yet less useful to a buyer who wants one palette for many moods.
My comparisons rely on the provided product details. I do not infer wear time, pigment strength, packaging quality, or performance beyond claims in those details. For example, Eclipse is described as designed for long wear and New Moon as designed to help reduce fallout; these are stated attributes, not guarantees of results. The information supplied for Ozian Forest does not include customer review content or wear claims, so I avoid ranking it on those points. The goal is to make each tradeoff visible, not to imply firsthand testing.
| celebrity makeup palette | Brand | Collection | Product type | Color range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: | ColourPop | The Twilight Saga: New Moon | Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | Warm neutrals, berry, and black |
| r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Go | r.e.m. beauty | Wicked: For Good | Eyeshadow palette | Forest greens, earthy neutrals, jewel tones, and pops of color |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | ColourPop | The Twilight Saga: Eclipse | Pressed powder eyeshadow palette | Silver, taupe, and blood red |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Celebrity Makeup Palettes
Celebrity collaborations often make their strongest impression through a recognizable theme, but I would choose by the color story and the looks you actually want to create. These three palettes are all eyeshadow-focused; none is presented as a full-face set. Use the guide below to decide whether breadth, green color, or a vampy edit should lead your choice.
Start with the looks you want to repeat
If you want one palette for softer makeup and occasional smoky definition, New Moon is the broadest match in this group. Its warm neutrals sit alongside berry and black, giving the color story more range than Eclipse’s silver, taupe, and blood red. That does not mean every shade will suit every buyer or every routine; it means the stated palette spans more familiar directions. Choose Ozian Forest instead if your regular makeup includes green or you want to explore that color without giving up all neutral options.
Eclipse is easiest to justify when its specific mood is the point. A buyer seeking cool, theatrical, or vampy looks may value that focus more than a wider everyday selection. By contrast, if you often reach for warm neutrals or want a palette to cover many occasions, its blood-red emphasis could leave some pans unused. I would decide on the color story before being swayed by the franchise name: the right collaboration is the one whose shades match your habits.
Compare shade count with color-story focus
New Moon and Eclipse each have 15 shades, while Ozian Forest has 12. More pans can offer more combinations, but shade count alone does not tell you how practical a palette is. New Moon’s count is paired with several color families and four stated finish types; Eclipse has the same number of pans but a tighter silver, taupe, and blood-red direction. Ozian Forest has fewer shades, yet its forest greens, earthy neutrals, jewel tones, and pops of color cover a distinctive range.
For a buyer who likes a clear, edited selection, 12 shades may feel more manageable than 15. For someone who values options, the ColourPop palettes offer more pans, but their different themes matter more than the numerical difference. Ask whether you want a palette with more room to combine colors or a more specific visual identity. In this particular lineup, Ozian Forest is the color experiment, New Moon is the flexible middle ground, and Eclipse is the focused statement.
Think about finishes and application preferences
All three include more than one finish, so none is a strictly matte-only option. New Moon combines matte, shimmer, pearlescent glitter, and metallic shades. That range can help create contrast in one palette, but it may not suit someone who prefers a low-shine routine. Eclipse includes matte, metallic, and glitter finishes, while Ozian Forest includes matte, shimmer, metallic, and a green duochrome. The duochrome is a particular reason to pick Ozian Forest if shifting color effects appeal to you.
Formula descriptions should be read as product claims rather than personal guarantees. New Moon is described as buildable and blendable, with design intended to help reduce fallout; Eclipse is described as pigmented and blendable, with long wear as an intended attribute; Ozian Forest is described as blendable. The available details do not establish identical wear, ease of blending, or fallout outcomes for every person. If you rely on specific performance traits, look for further product information before choosing, especially for Ozian Forest, where wear details are absent.
Check availability and what is not specified
Both ColourPop Twilight palettes are described as limited edition. That status can matter if you want to replace a palette later or prefer not to make a decision around a collection that may be temporary. It is also a reason not to assume future availability. The provided details do not state that application brushes or other tools are included with either ColourPop palette, so buyers should plan on using their own tools unless the listing confirms otherwise.
The product information differs in how clearly it covers formula and use. New Moon is explicitly identified as vegan and cruelty-free; Eclipse is identified as cruelty-free, with vegan status not specified in the provided details. Ozian Forest’s details describe its colors and finishes but do not establish wear time or customer feedback. Those information gaps do not automatically count against a formula, but they may matter to buyers who use animal-testing criteria or want performance claims before purchase. Compare the information actually supplied rather than assuming two products from a collaboration format share the same attributes.
Match the palette to your tolerance for bold shades
Each palette has a different level and kind of color commitment. New Moon spreads its range across warm neutrals, berry, and black, so it offers more obvious starting points for everyday looks alongside darker ones. Ozian Forest puts green at the center but balances it with earthy neutrals. Eclipse is the boldest commitment in a specific direction: blood red and silver make its identity unmistakable, but that may narrow its use for someone who prefers understated makeup.
Consider how often you reach for color, not just whether you like the theme in a product photo or description. If statement shades tend to sit untouched in your collection, New Moon may be the most sensible choice of the three. If green is a regular part of your makeup, Ozian Forest’s theme is a reason to choose it rather than a compromise. If you already know that you enjoy cool, vampy looks, Eclipse’s narrower palette can be an advantage instead of a limitation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these celebrity makeup palettes is the most versatile?
I rank ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon as the most versatile of these three because its warm neutrals, berry, and black shades cover more than one clear direction. Its matte, shimmer, pearlescent glitter, and metallic finishes add further variety. Ozian Forest is also designed to support everyday or dramatic looks, but its defining feature is a green-centered story. Eclipse is more focused on silver, taupe, and blood red, making it the better match for a narrower vampy style rather than the broadest range.
Which palette should I choose if I want green eyeshadow?
r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest is the direct choice for green shades. Its described range includes forest greens and a green duochrome, alongside earthy neutrals and jewel tones. New Moon and Eclipse have different strengths: New Moon covers warm neutrals, berry, and black, while Eclipse focuses on silver, taupe, and blood red. If green is the main reason for buying, Ozian Forest is a better match than choosing one of the Twilight palettes and hoping its color story meets that need.
Which palette is best for dramatic or vampy looks?
Eclipse is the clearest fit if you specifically want a cool, vampy look built around silver, taupe, and blood red. It also includes matte, metallic, and glitter finishes, with a formula described as blendable and designed for long wear. New Moon can create smoky looks too, thanks to berry and black shades, but it offers warm neutrals as well. Ozian Forest is the better dramatic choice if you want your bold color to center on greens rather than red or silver.
Are these full makeup kits or eyeshadow palettes?
The supplied product information describes all three as eyeshadow palettes, not full-face makeup kits. It does not establish that brushes or application tools are included. New Moon’s details specifically say application tools are not specified, and tools are also not confirmed in the information provided for Eclipse or Ozian Forest. If included accessories matter, check the current product listing rather than assuming the palette comes with brushes.
Which details should I verify before buying?
I would check current availability, the exact listed shade information, and any formula or animal-testing details that matter to you. New Moon and Eclipse are identified as limited-edition collections, so continued availability is not assured. New Moon is listed as vegan and cruelty-free, while Eclipse is listed as cruelty-free but not confirmed as vegan in the provided details. Ozian Forest’s supplied information does not establish wear time or customer feedback, so buyers who need those details should seek current product information before deciding.
Conclusion
For the broadest all-round color story in this comparison, I recommend ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon. Its warm neutrals, berry, and black make it the most adaptable starting point, and its four listed finish types add options for buyers who enjoy texture. Choose r.e.m. beauty x Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest if green shades and a duochrome matter more than having 15 pans; its earthy neutrals give the color-led palette a softer side. Pick ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse if you specifically want cool silver, taupe, and blood-red shades for a vampy look. I would not select Eclipse as a general-purpose palette unless that focused mood is exactly what you want. These are all eyeshadow collaborations, so check current availability and confirm any accessory or formula details that are essential to your routine.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
